First Railway - Its confusing

snaggs
snaggs's picture
Posts: 4
Joined: 2007-08-28
No votes yet

Location(s)

Perth, WA
Australia
I'm researching for a first railway set for my son and I, and its confusing. To make things simple, I'd decided to standardize on Kato and model a Japanese city, since there are so many more buildings etc available. However Kato seem to still be half-way between DC and embracing DCC. Here are my questions;

1. Is there a N Scale track design program? I want to pick a small japanese city somewhere and model it, its confusing to know what track is needed, so I thought there must be some kind of computer program?

2. It seems pointless to start now with a DC setup. However, DCC is so confusing, different sound chips, different control chips etc etc, some compatible with some trains, some not. Is there a list somewhere of DCC Ready Kato trains and a recommendation of the best chip for them? I'm not worried about cost, I only intend to have one train (ot maybe twi) to start with.

3. Can anybody recommend any DCC Equipped out of the box with sound diesel engines suitable for Japanese modeling?

4. Have Kato announced intention of committing to DCC?  A Kato DCC box set would just be perfect!

Daniel.



railohio
railohio's picture
Posts: 1030
Joined: 2004-01-02
nScale.net Forum Moderator
The best way I've found to
The best way I've found to learn about Japan's railroads is to learn Japanese. I have a couple books on Japanese railroads that I can't read, but at least I can admire the photography for now.
--
mmmmm pie!



David Masten
David Masten's picture
Posts: 79
Joined: 2007-10-22
Railway design programs and DCC

3rd Planit, CADRail, and XTrackCad are all good design programs. They aren't scale specific because computers are real good at handling scaling issues. I believe all of them have Kato track libraries available for them.

DCC is really not confusing - you'll need a command station/booster (the central brains) from one vendor. The decoders (chips that go in each train, with and without sound) can be from any vendor. Do a search on the forums, there is a lot of good discussion on DCC systems.

Kato is  in the enviable position of doing such good work over the years that they have some very popular gear from pre-DCC days. They can't really discontinue those items due to popularity, but they are a real pain to make DCC. The USRA Mikado being the prime example here. Again search is your friend, not only here but also the Kato web site and Google.




snaggs
snaggs's picture
Posts: 4
Joined: 2007-08-28
Kato DCC

Well, I've done some research and Kato have a DCC controller and also some chips. 

http://www.katomodels.com/hobby/dcc/start.shtml

However, its difficult to work out what chips you need for each piece, do I need a lighting chip for every car? which chip goes in the loco? It appears they have a number of trains which are ready to accept these chips without soldering or modifications.

I can't put together a shopping list of codes to order.

 Daniel. 




Walleye
Walleye's picture
Posts: 19
Joined: 2008-01-16
Daniel,First of all, ANY

Daniel,

First of all, ANY DCC decoder ("chip") will work with ANY controller. There is absolutely no reason to restrict yourself to controller and decoders from the same manufacturer. The NMRA standards are (surprisingly) universally adhered to.

Second, the Kato controller shown on the site you referenced is actually a Digitrax Zephyr with labels in Japanese. Search the Web and you'll find lots of information about this product.

Third, the only manufacturer I know who makes DCC sound decoders for N scale is MRC. And their decoders (but not their other products) are universally reviled! If there are alternatives in the Japanese market, you might try them.

-Wayne




Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Powered by Drupal - Modified by Todd Vaules