JL Innovative Design Ice House

absnut
absnut's picture
Posts: 626
Joined: 2004-01-12
nScale.net Site Supporter
No votes yet

After taking a couple months hiatus from modeling while I got over surgery and lack of energy, I have, again,  begun to address the needs of my layout.  First order of business was the long over-due conversion of an MDC/Athearn Overland combine to resemble B&M's #1111, Air Brake Instruction car.  Feeling good about the results, I went in search of building kits, JL Innovative Design's Brookside Ice House, having been intriquing for some time, became a must.  Thanks to Mike Fifer, I quickly had one to hand and have started it.

First impression:  after having built models in practically every medium since the early 50's, I am no stranger to modeling challenges but... it just might turn out that "challenge" is an inadequate term to describe this kit.  Nicely done,  there are many small parts, wood, plastic, and  paper.  I will have to reserve comment on the two pages of instructions until later.  It might not be an ideal kit for someone who has yet to build a wood kit and it's certainly not for the faint of heart.  I may have to re-evaluate my impressions as I proceed.

At this point, I have spray painted the wood parts (not the strips) with Testors gray primer enamel.  This will give a good base coat without warping.  The finished building will get a coat of Poly S over the primer.  Light sanding will remove some of the Poly S leaving gray "weathered wood" showing.  More later as I wander through the construction phases.


--

Dick,

Usually, when all is said and done, there's a lot more said than done!




Jimmi
Jimmi's picture
Posts: 827
Joined: 2006-12-18
nScale.net Site Supporter
Dick,The 1111 really came

Dick,

The 1111 really came out nice!  Looks like lots of small parts in the ice house kit.  As someone who just tonight pried a super glued NJ International cantilever signal bridge from his fingers, good luck with the kit.


--

The secret of success is sincerity. Once you can fake that, you've got it made.    Jean Giraudoux

Jim




absnut
absnut's picture
Posts: 626
Joined: 2004-01-12
nScale.net Site Supporter
I can change my mind if I want to.....

Day Two on this project and I have modified my original assessment slightly.  After getting over the original shock, I attacked with firm resolve to see it through!  It is a moderately difficult kit but, if one has had a little experience building wood kits, it is not impossible.  Having too much experience building wood kits and scratch building could be a slight impediment in that we all have our own ways of doing things and just might modify the directions to align them with our own ways of thinking but.... in this case, DON'T!  Read the directions carefully (at least twice) and follow them to the letter.  Measure twice before cutting, referring to the directions once again between measurements.  The directions are well written and once understood are good.  Being a "visual learner", I found it difficult to visualize some of the assembly steps and wished there were a few drawings to illustate some of them.  However, after making the various sub-assemblies, studying the two drawings, re-reading the directions, and making several trial fittings, I got the various parts of the building to fit together in what appeared to be the proper fashion.

Rather than paint the building a dark color (as per the photo), I reckoned an ice house would be better painted a lighter color as a dark surface absorbs heat and would be detrimental to the well being of any ice stored inside.  Having depot buff on hand, that's the color I used along with a dark green for trim.  One coat of Poly S depot buff laid thinly, then sanded lightly when dry, gave the building a slightly worn look.

Cutting and assembling the braces for the icing platform was a little tedious (and time consuming) but, the job went well.  The photo shows how far I have progressed.  The work has been slow but, I am thinking it will all be worth it as it is shaping up to be a fine looking building with nice detail.  I think I'll be able to finish it up tonight.  More later......

Thanks for the kudos, Jim. Laughing


--

Dick,

Usually, when all is said and done, there's a lot more said than done!




absnut
absnut's picture
Posts: 626
Joined: 2004-01-12
nScale.net Site Supporter
Done

It's been a long time since a modeling project stretched over four days for me.  I worked over 36 hours on a scratch-built Schnabel several years ago but, I was making up the directions as I went along!  This kit required a good deal of unanticipated time (for me) in that the directions needed constant re-reading and there was a lot of pre-painting (not to mention several fiddly-small parts!)  However, I is a nice kit and resulted in a nice model icehouse.

I encountered a few problems but, none were insurmountable:  I felt a few of the measurements in the directions were off but correctable.  While I normally like to use fine emory paper or black construction paper for tar paper roofs, I used the enclosed material and directions which, after painting, resulted in a bubbly, wavy roof.  I removed the strips and substituted with construction paper, gluing down with Goo.... no problems after painting this time.  The stair railings and safety railings did not appear to be the same as in the photo on the box but.... I trimmed the stair railings, patching them to fit, and replaced the safety railings on the platform/cupola with some I had in my scrap box, since they definitely did not fit the need.

 In summation, this turned out to be a nice kit.  If you like one evening projects.... this is not one of those.  If you don't mind spreading the project out over several sessions, it will go nicely.  I still do not recommend this as a first wood-built project but, with a little experience with wood kits, careful reading and adherance to directions, and careful assembly,  the results will be quite rewarding.

Photos show I need a little touch up paint (always visible to the camera! LOL)  One final touch will be to install window glass with Micro Krystal Klear.


--

Dick,

Usually, when all is said and done, there's a lot more said than done!




Bryan
Bryan's picture
Posts: 4174
Joined: 2004-02-29
nScale.net Site Administrator
Nice work, Dick... your
Nice work, Dick... your time on the road away from a hobby desk didn't dilute your skills Wink
--

Bryan




69Z28
69Z28's picture
Posts: 1105
Joined: 2006-03-19
nScale.net Site Supporter
DickThat is beautifully

Dick

That is beautifully executed build of the kit. The  information from your posts will help me because I have that kit. 

I'll print off your suggestions and directions and put them in the box. Then move it back in the line and hope it turns out (dream) as well as yours.  

See ya

Ron


--
Ya gots ta choose. Sometimes ya wins and sometimes ya lose.


absnut
absnut's picture
Posts: 626
Joined: 2004-01-12
nScale.net Site Supporter
Thanks, gents
Thanks for the kind comments, gents.  Ron, if you have any questions, please feel free to PM me and I'll be happy to share some of my frustrations! LOL YellLaughing
--

Dick,

Usually, when all is said and done, there's a lot more said than done!




absnut
absnut's picture
Posts: 626
Joined: 2004-01-12
nScale.net Site Supporter
Addenda

When I ordered the ice house kit from Mike Fifer, I also got a Northeastern freight house and a Walthers tenement building (for background) to add to two others I have.  The tenements will look nice when detailed with washing, people, etc.  The Northeastern kit went together really nice, quickly, and is very solid.  I needed to add my own details and roofing but, it was a good buy.


--

Dick,

Usually, when all is said and done, there's a lot more said than done!




Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Powered by Drupal - Modified by Todd Vaules